EAST COAST FURNITECH PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: ECF🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Introduction

The Company prioritizes the implementation of an effective internal control system at both the management and operational levels to ensure efficiency and effectiveness in operations at all levels. At the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 1/2007 held on February 28, 2007, all attending audit committee members assessed the adequacy of the Company's internal control system using an internal control adequacy assessment form covering five areas: Control Environment, Risk Assessment, Control Activities, Information and Communication, and Monitoring Activities.

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the Company has an adequate and appropriate internal control system in place for transactions with major shareholders, directors, executives, or persons related to such persons. The approval of such transactions is fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the Company, and is treated as a transaction with an unrelated party. The approval of such transactions shall be made only by persons who have no interest in such transactions.


With regard to internal control, the Company has an Audit Committee which is responsible for reviewing the Company's internal control and internal audit systems to ensure they are appropriate, sufficient, and effective. The Audit Committee reviews the adequacy of the Company's and its subsidiaries' internal control and operating systems in five areas: corporate governance, risk assessment, control activities, information systems and communication, and monitoring systems. This review is conducted in conjunction with the Company's auditors, internal auditors, and management to ensure that the Company's operations comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, the Stock Exchange of Thailand's regulations, and other applicable laws. The Audit Committee reports its findings to the Board of Directors. The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company's and its subsidiaries' internal control systems are adequate and appropriate.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM)

The Company has established an internal audit unit to function within the Company  and attend Audit Committee meetings to report on internal audit findings. The unit comprises Ms. Phimramphai Boonchana, along with an external auditor hired by the Company, Act Plus Consultant Co., Ltd., with Ms. Wanna Maluengnon (Managing Director of Act Plus Consultant Co., Ltd.) as the head of the internal audit unit. The unit is responsible for auditing and establishing an internal control system for the Company to enhance checks and balances in the operations of all departments. The Company has engaged Act Plus Consultant Co., Ltd. since the third quarter of 2011.


The Company has ensured sufficient personnel to effectively implement the system. The Company also has an internal control system to monitor and supervise the operations of subsidiaries and associated companies to safeguard the assets of the Company, subsidiaries, and associated companies from unauthorized or improper use by the directors or management.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years AgoRemark
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)10114All deficiencies identified in 2022 have been fully resolved. Most of the deficiencies in 2023 and 2024, which are primarily related to general documentation, have also been addressed.

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2024-012024-03
There is no formal appointment of a Data Protection Officer (DPO) and a Data Protection Committee (DPO).
Incident no longer subject to action

Appoint a Data Protection Officer (DPO) and a Data Protection Working Group (DPO) in writing, with clearly defined roles, responsibilities, and contact information.

month/year Range2024-012024-03
There are no policy reviews related to personal data protection.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company shall review its policies related to personal data protection annually or when there are changes in relevant laws.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Regarding the review, the customer credit limit review adheres to the established plan and is conducted with fairness.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company requires a review of customer credit at least annually or whenever there are changes. In addition, there is a notification system when any debtor exceeds the credit limit.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Suggestions for improvement include increasing the lighting in the warehouse area and adding more fire extinguishers to align with the quantity of goods stored.
Incident no longer subject to action

1. The company has installed spotlights to increase the illumination within the warehouse area adequately.

2. Installed additional fire extinguishers inside the warehouse according to the map that the safety officer proposed to the risk management team.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3159

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Audit Committee is of the opinion that it has supervised the Head of Internal Audit to have the appropriate educational qualifications, experience, and training sufficient for such duties. At the Audit Committee meeting on August 14, 2021, Meeting No. 3/2021, Ms. Phimramphai Boonchana was appointed as the Acting Head of Internal Audit, an internal personnel of the Company, effective from August 15, 2021. This appointment is due to her experience in internal audit work and her thorough knowledge of the Company's internal control system. She also has a good understanding of the Company's activities and operations. Therefore, the Committee believes that she is suitable and capable of performing such duties effectively, including the duties of the Head of Compliance Department to oversee the Company's operations to comply with the rules, regulations, or requirements set by the regulatory authorities related to the Company's business.


In addition, the Company has also hired an external auditor, Act-Plus Consultant Co., Ltd., with Ms. Wanna Maluengnon (Managing Director of Act-Plus Consultant Co., Ltd.) as the Head of Internal Audit. The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of Act-Plus Consultant Co., Ltd. and Ms. Wanna Maluengnon and believes that they are qualified for such duties. This is because they are independent and have experience in internal audit work for various businesses and industries for more than 20 years. They have also been trained in courses related to internal audit work, such as the Risk Management Program for Corporate Leader (RCL5/2016) by the Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) and the Internal Audit Training Course on Fraud Audit organized by the Federation of Accounting Professions, etc.


The Company has also appointed a Head of Internal Audit who is an employee of the Company to coordinate with the outsourced auditor.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The appointment, removal, and transfer of the Head of Internal Audit shall be approved by the Audit Committee.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Index Living Mall Public Company LimitedJuristic PersonThailand's leading integrated retailer of furniture and home furnishing products

There is a director who is the spouse of Mr. Pacharatanapong Suksawad, who holds the position of shareholder, director, and authorized director. and executives of the company

2024-12-31T00:00
Index Interfern Company LimitedJuristic PersonDesigner, Producer, and Distributor of furniture products

There is a director who is the spouse of Mr. Pacharatanapong Suksawad, who holds the position of shareholder, director, and authorized director. and executives of the company

2024-12-31T00:00
Botlink Company LimitedJuristic PersonRobot service providers in the form of delivery robots, cleaning robots, and more with AI technology.

The directors and shareholders are Mr. Pacharatanapong Suksawad, who holds the position of shareholder, director, authorized signatory director, and executive of the Company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr. Wanlop SuksawadPerson

who holds the position of authorized signatory of the Company

2024-12-31T00:00
Mrs.Waraporn SuksawadPerson

Wife of Mr. Wanlop Suksawad who is an authorized signatory of the Company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr.Pacharatanapong SuksawadPerson

Who Holds the position of shareholder, authorized signatory director, and executive of the Company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Miss Tippawan SuksawadPerson

The daughter of Mr. Wanlop Suksawad and Mr. Pacharatanapong Suksawad, both of them are directors of the Company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Miss Kridchanok PattamasuttayasonthiPerson

Those who live together as husband and wife of Mr. Pacharatanapong Suksawad.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
274.53 · Necessity: The Company sells particle board furniture to Index Living Mall, starting in September 2012, with the selling price determined based on the Company’s pricing criteria, which is fair and an arm’s length basis. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 202.66 · Nature of transaction: The Company sells particle board furniture. · Audit committee opinion: The selling price is determined following the Company's pricing criteria, which are fair and an arm's length basis. · As of year before yesteryear: 42.27 · 0.0 · Necessity: It is caused by the outstanding payment for goods with the Company, where the said debt has not yet reached the due date for payment. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 60.61 · Nature of transaction: Accounts Receivable · Audit committee opinion: Following the normal practice of business operations · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 0.0 · Necessity: Since some items need to be sent for repair, Index Living Mall has considered repairing itself and will charge the company for the cost. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Repair product service · Audit committee opinion: Considered that the price was reasonable and in line with normal business practices. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 1.44 · Necessity: To participate in the product promotion organized by Index Living Mall. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Advertising expense · Audit committee opinion: Considered that the price was reasonable and in line with normal business practices. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.26 · 0.0 · Necessity: It was caused by the advertising cost that had not reached the payment cycle. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Other accounts payable · Audit committee opinion: Following the normal practice of business operations · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 3.14 · Necessity: The Company orders fabric and PVC edges for use in producing some products for sale to Index Living Mall. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Raw materials purchasing · Audit committee opinion: Considered that the price was reasonable and in line with normal business practices. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.39 · Necessity: This is an item that occurred from the Company ordering fabric and PVC edges to be used in the production of some products for sale to Index Living Mall before the payment cycle has arrived. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Accounts payable · Audit committee opinion: Following the normal practice of business operations · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 20.41 · Necessity: Conditions are as mutually agreed upon between the Company and the purchaser. · Description: Since Index Living Mall has ordered products from the Company, there are conditions for receiving advance payment for the products as mutually agreed upon. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Advance payment for goods · Audit committee opinion: Consider that it is in accordance with the mutually agreed terms and conditions and is an item that is beneficial to the Company. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
16.85 · Necessity: The Company distributes surface paper products to Index Interfern Co., Ltd., starting in 2010. · Description: Since the company manufactures furniture for Index Living Mall in some categories, it is necessary to purchase decorative paper and PVC edges to use as raw materials for furniture production for the Index Living Mall group. At the same time, the Company also sells decorative paper to Index Interfern for use in furniture production as well. · As of yesteryear: 14.86 · Nature of transaction: Selling decorative paper · Audit committee opinion: The selling price is determined following the Company's pricing criteria, which are fair and on an arm's length basis. · As of year before yesteryear: 13.25 · 4.48 · Necessity: It is caused by the outstanding payment for goods with the Company, where the said debt has not yet reached the due date for payment. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 5.31 · Nature of transaction: Accounts Receivable · Audit committee opinion: Following the normal practice of business operations · As of year before yesteryear: 4.38 · 0.0 · Necessity: The Company orders PVC edge and decorative paper from Index Interfern to produce some products for sale to Index Living Mall. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 4.52 · Nature of transaction: Purchasing the raw materials · Audit committee opinion: The selling price is determined following the Company's pricing criteria, which are fair and on an arm's length basis. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: It arose from the company ordering decorative paper and PVC edges from Index Interfern to produce some products for sale to Index Living Mall. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 1.14 · Nature of transaction: Accounts payable · Audit committee opinion: Following the normal practice of business operations · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
1.89 · Necessity: The Company purchases wireless automatic swimming pool cleaning robots to sell through the Company's online sales channels. · Description: It is a product procurement to increase opportunities and generate income for the Company. · As of yesteryear: 0.21 · Nature of transaction: Purchasing a product · Audit committee opinion: The pricing of the purchase and sale between each other is based on the normal pricing criteria of the business operation, which is fair and at arm’s length basis. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 1.25 · Necessity: The Company has outstanding payments for the purchase of swimming pool cleaning robots. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 0.17 · Nature of transaction: Accounts Payable · Audit committee opinion: Following the normal practice of business operations · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
0.13 · Necessity: To develop the land into a warehouse to store the Company's stock. · Description: The rental rate is as assessed by the SEC-approved appraisal company and as approved by the Company's Board of Directors Meeting No. 6/2022 on August 11, 2022. · As of yesteryear: 0.13 · Nature of transaction: Land lease under a lease agreement for construction and use as the Company's warehouse. · Audit committee opinion: Considered that the rental price is appropriate and consistent with the appraisal price conducted by an independent appraiser and that the transaction is for the benefit of the Company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.02 · Necessity: It was caused by the outstanding amount of land rental payments that were not yet due. · Description: None · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Other accounts payable · Audit committee opinion: Following the normal practice of business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 14.5 · Necessity: To enhance the liquidity of the Company's business operations. · Description: The Company has borrowed money at an interest rate of 5.25 percent per annum and is due for repayment upon request. · As of yesteryear: 29.0 · Nature of transaction: Lending to the Company · Audit committee opinion: Considered that it is under the mutually agreed terms and conditions and for the benefit of the Company, as the interest rate is lower than when compared to requesting a loan from a financial institution, which is fair, reasonable, and for the benefit of the Company. In addition, the Company is not required to provide any collateral to guarantee the said loan. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
4.82 · Necessity: To enhance the liquidity of the Company's business operations. · Description: The Company has borrowed money at an interest rate of 5.25 percent per annum and is due for repayment upon request. · As of yesteryear: 36.0 · Nature of transaction: Lending to the Company · Audit committee opinion: Considered that it is under the mutually agreed terms and conditions and for the benefit of the Company, as the interest rate is lower than when compared to requesting a loan from a financial institution, which is fair, reasonable, and for the benefit of the Company. In addition, the Company is not required to provide any collateral to guarantee the said loan. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
4.73 · Necessity: To enhance the liquidity of the Company's business operations. · Description: The Company has borrowed money at an interest rate of 5.25 percent per annum and is due for repayment upon request. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Lending to the Company · Audit committee opinion: Considered that it is under the mutually agreed terms and conditions and for the benefit of the Company, as the interest rate is lower than when compared to requesting a loan from a financial institution, which is fair, reasonable, and for the benefit of the Company. In addition, the Company is not required to provide any collateral to guarantee the said loan. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
20.0 · Necessity: To enhance the liquidity of the Company's business operations. · Description: The Company has borrowed money at an interest rate of 7 percent per annum and is due for repayment upon request. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Lending to the Company · Audit committee opinion: Considered that it is under the mutually agreed terms and conditions and for the benefit of the Company, as the interest rate is lower than when compared to requesting a loan from a financial institution, which is fair, reasonable, and for the benefit of the Company. In addition, the Company is not required to provide any collateral to guarantee the said loan. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

In the event of any related party transaction between the Company or its subsidiaries and related persons, persons who may have conflicts of interest, have vested interests or may have conflicts of interest in the future, which is a commercial agreement in the same manner as what a reasonable person would do with a general contracting party in the same situation, with the bargaining power of trade without the influence of being a director, executive, or related person, and with normal trading conditions or market prices, under reasonable conditions, which can be verified, and do not result in the transfer of benefits, the Company's management can proceed as usual under the principles that the Company's board of directors has considered and approved, and to prepare a summary report to report to the Audit Committee every quarter.


In the event of any related party transaction that is not a normal trading transaction, the Company will arrange for the Audit Committee to have an opinion on the necessity and appropriateness of such transaction. In the event that the Audit Committee does not have expertise in considering the related party transaction that may occur, the Company will consider having an independent appraiser, an independent specialist, or an auditor provides an opinion on such related party transaction to the Audit Committee, so that the Audit Committee can use it in making a decision and provide an opinion to the Company's board of directors or shareholders, as the case may be, to approve such transaction before entering into the transaction. The Company will disclose the related party transaction in the notes to the financial statements that have been audited by the Company's auditor. and such related party transactions shall be disclosed in the annual information disclosure form (Form 56-1 One Report) in accordance with the criteria and laws governing securities and exchange. However, consideration and approval of such related party transactions must be in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, in which persons who may have conflicts of interest or have an interest in such related party transactions shall not have the right to vote on such related party transactions.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

In the future, if the Company needs to enter into any related party transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest with the Company, the Company will set the conditions to be in accordance with the nature of normal business operations and be market prices that can be referenced and compared with the conditions or prices that occur in the same type of business that the Company does with external parties. The Company will have the Audit Committee provide opinions on the price, and compensation rates, as well as the necessity and appropriateness of such related party transactions. In the event that the Audit Committee does not have expertise in considering the related party transactions that may occur, the Company will consider having an independent appraiser, an independent specialist, or the Company's auditor provide opinions on such related party transactions so that the Audit Committee can use them to make decisions and provide opinions to the Company's Board of Directors or shareholders, as appropriate.


The Company will disclose such related party transactions in the notes to the financial statements that have been audited by the Company's auditors and will disclose such related party transactions in the annual information disclosure form (Form 56-1 One Report) in accordance with the criteria and laws governing securities and exchange, and the regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand.


For any related party transactions that may occur in the future, the directors must comply with the regulations that have been established and the directors must not approve any transactions in which they or persons may have conflicts of interest in any other manner with the Company and must disclose such transactions that the Company Must comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, announcements, orders or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the requirements regarding disclosure of information on related party transactions and the acquisition or disposal of the Company's or its subsidiaries' assets and in strict accordance with the prescribed accounting standards. In addition, the Company will not enter into any transactions with related companies that are not in the normal course of business of the Company.

Contents