EAST COAST FURNITECH PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: ECF🇹🇭 TH

MD&A · 2024

Overview of Operations

Overview of Operations

The Company manufactures and distributes furniture products for household use, ranging from bedroom sets, living rooms, dining tables, and sofas, both in self-assembly and ready-to-assemble formats. The Company's main customer groups are currently domestic customers, approximately 60%, and exports, approximately 40%. The main domestic customer groups are large retailers (Thai Hypermarkets), followed by small retailers nationwide, and distribution through various online platforms.


For international customers, the Company has major customers in Japan, India, the United States, and the Philippines.


Revenue from sales and total revenue for the year 2023 decreased slightly compared to the same period last year, with revenue from sales at 1,345.82 million baht and total revenue at 1,363.43 million baht. The proportion of cost of sales to revenue from sales increased significantly. The proportion of distribution costs, administrative expenses, and financial costs to total revenue remained similar to the previous year. In addition, the company had significant expenses to comply with accounting standards, including increased allowance for impairment of financial assets and allowance for obsolete inventory in Q4.

Operating Results & Financial Condition

Operating Results & Profitability

2024 Operating Results


For 2024, the Company had revenue from its business operations and revenue from subsidiaries of 1,345.82 million baht and total revenue of 1,363.43 million baht, a slight decrease compared to the previous year of 2.09 percent and 1.93 percent, respectively. This decrease in revenue was due to the impact of exports to India, the continued slowdown in exports to Japan, and the economic slowdown in the country, which also affected Hypermarket group revenue in the fourth quarter.


The Company's sales mix between exports and domestic sales in 2024 was 40 percent and 60 percent, respectively, or 549.55 million baht and 796.27 million baht, respectively. The proportion of exports remained similar to the previous year. Domestic sales decreased slightly by 3 percent due to the economic slowdown in the country towards the end of 2024.


The Company's other income, which consists of income from the sale of production materials and scrap, amounted to 8.04 million baht, and other income was 7.85 million baht, resulting in a total of 15.89 million baht. This is close to the previous year's value of 14.73 million baht. Additionally, the company had financial income of 23.63 million baht, a decrease compared to the previous year's financial income of 27.28 million baht.


The share of profit from investments in associates was derived from Green Earth Power (Thailand) Co., Ltd. (GEP), which is an investor in a 220-megawatt solar power plant project in Minbu, Myanmar. ECF Power Co., Ltd. (ECF-P), a subsidiary of the company, invested in GEP, accounting for 20 percent. Currently, there is commercial revenue for the 50-megawatt Phase 1 project, and GEP is in the process of constructing Phase 2 and will expedite the construction of the remaining phases to complete all four phases as soon as possible.


Currently, electricity payments from the Myanmar Electric Power Enterprise (MEPE) are still following the specified conditions.


Significant Costs and Expenses Incurred in 2024


The cost of sales ratio for 2024 increased to 89.18 percent, which is still higher compared to the same period of the previous year, which had a ratio of 81.07 percent. The main reason is the significant increase in cost of sales in the fourth quarter, which affected the overall picture and resulted in a significant increase in the cost of sales ratio. This was due to pushing sales of old inventory by offering customer discounts of 10-20 percent, as well as product improvements during production to create benefits, resulting in losses from new packaging of approximately 20-25 percent. This was also impacted by the continuous increase in raw material and labor costs.


The proportion of distribution costs and administrative expenses remained similar to the previous year. Significant expenses included an increase in the allowance for obsolete inventory in the fourth quarter of 10 million baht.


Additionally, there is a significant difference in revenue. In the same period of the previous year, the company recognized insurance compensation received from a fire incident that occurred in April 2023, amounting to 92.28 million baht. This was recognized as a deduction from the company's total expenses as a special item that occurred in the third quarter of the previous year.


The proportion of financial costs remained similar to the previous year, and the company recognized an increase in accounting expenses from the increase in impairment losses on financial assets in the fourth quarter. This was due to an increase in allowance for doubtful accounts of 17.20 million baht and the impairment of investments in ECF Holdings Co., Ltd., a subsidiary, which had a net loss exceeding its equity and whose profitability remained poor. Therefore, this year, there was an increase in the loss on impairment of investments of 21.25 million baht.


Throughout 2024, the company implemented new work improvement processes, considered price adjustments for products to align with costs and the current production situation. Distribution costs and administrative expenses remain under continuous cost control policies. Additionally, the company is in the process of addressing high financial costs to expedite their reduction as soon as possible.


Profitability in 2024


Gross profit decreased due to the increased proportion of cost of sales, with a gross profit value of 129.98 million baht. However, the company had a loss before interest and income tax of 115.40 million baht and a net loss attributable to owners of the parent company (ECF) of 231.37 million baht. This was due to the aforementioned increase in costs and expenses during 2024.


Financial Position of the Company: Consolidated Financial Statements as of December 31, 2024


The company had total assets of 3,880.17 million baht as of December 31, 2024, a decrease of 154 million baht from the previous year. This was due to a decrease in trade receivables, as the company was able to collect receivables better, and in line with the decrease in the average collection period from 162 days in the previous year to 140 days in 2024.


The company had total liabilities of 2,936.41 million baht as of December 31, 2024, an increase of 82 million baht from December 31, 2023. The main reason for this increase was the increase in short-term loans from other persons to enhance liquidity for business operations.


Equity attributable to owners of the parent company as of December 31, 2024, was 943.76 million baht. Equity decreased due to the net loss.


As of December 31, 2024, the company had a debt-to-equity ratio of 3.11 times, an increase compared to December 31, 2023, which had a ratio of 2.42 times. This increase is due to higher debt burdens. However, the company is actively seeking ways to reduce its total debt, including current financial costs, as quickly as possible. The company has scheduled an Extraordinary General Meeting of Shareholders No. 1/2025 on March 5, 2025. The meeting will propose important agendas for approval, including an increase in registered capital of no more than 300 million baht, with a par value of 0.25 baht per share, and the allocation of such newly issued ordinary shares for offering to private placement investors.

Liquidity & Capital Adequacy

As of December 31, 2017, the Company had a current ratio of 0.64 times, decreasing from the previous year with a ratio of 0.88 times, and a quick ratio of 0.14 times, decreasing from the previous year with a ratio of 0.28 times. However, the cash flow liquidity ratio slightly increased from the previous year with a ratio of 0.07 times to 0.08 times, due to the Company’s increased cash flow from operations. As of December 31, 2017, it was valued at Baht 181.84 million, increasing from the previous year with a value of Baht 148.05 million. The important reason was due to the improved collection of accounts receivable and in line with the collection period, which decreased from 162 days in the previous year to 140 days in 2017.


However, the Company’s overall liquidity decreased from the increased value of current liabilities, which resulted from the increase in short-term loans from other persons by Baht 223.29 million compared to the previous year. The value of such items as of December 31, 2017 was Baht 378.18 million. Such borrowings were mainly for enhancing the Company's liquidity and capital adequacy. In addition, the Company had debentures due within 1 year increased from Baht 606.04 million from the previous year to Baht 879.41 million as of December 31, 2017, which was in accordance with the upcoming debenture repayment conditions.

Asset Management Capability

As of December 31, 2023, the Company had efficiency ratios for return on assets, return on fixed assets, and asset turnover ratio of -5.88%, 21.32%, and 0.34 times, respectively. The key reason for the negative return or asset management efficiency was the Company's net loss attributable to the parent company of 231.37 million baht.

Debt Obligations & Off-Balance-Sheet Management

As of December 31, 2024, the company has a significant debt obligation: the value of debentures due within 1 year is 879.41 million baht, which is in accordance with the bond repayment conditions that will occur within the second quarter of 2025.


The Company has considered the following liquidity management and debt repayment plan:


1. Adjusting the operational plan by effectively managing costs to reduce unnecessary expenses, downsizing the organization, adjusting product prices to plan for increased profits, which has been implemented since the beginning of 2025.

2. Seeking short-term funding sources both domestically and internationally to enhance liquidity and support the company's purchase orders, and to enable the business to continue operating smoothly. The company has already initiated some of these plans by issuing and offering newly issued ordinary shares to private placement investors, with a schedule for the 2025 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders No. 1/2025 on March 5, 2025. The amount expected to be issued and offered for sale is 75-100 million baht.

3. Seeking additional sources of funding from abroad, which will be used as a source of funds to solve the problem of bond repayment that will mature within 2025.

4. For the solar power plant project in Minbu, Myanmar, the company has concluded negotiations with a contractor from China and has signed a Settlement Agreement together in early November. This will be the starting point for moving forward with the construction of phases 2 and 3 together. Currently, there are financial institutions from abroad ready to support the construction. If the approval is granted, the company will be able to build confidence among domestic financial institutions to increase the opportunity to receive higher credit lines. The company will also be able to adjust the collateral structure, which currently has a collateral value higher than the debt owed to financial institutions. However, due to the current economic slowdown, the original financial institutions are not ready to provide additional credit lines, even though the collateral value is higher than the current debt.

Material & Related-Party Transactions

At the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 1/2025 held on January 17, 2025, the Board of Directors approved (a) the reduction of the Company's registered capital by 2,517.75 Baht (by canceling 10,071 unissued ordinary shares with a par value of 0.25 Baht per share) from 359,814,618 Baht to 359,812,100.25 Baht, divided into 1,439,248,401 ordinary shares with a par value of 0.25 Baht per share, and (b) the increase of the Company's registered capital by 75,000,000 Baht (from 359,812,100.25 Baht to 434,812,100.25 Baht) by issuing 300,000,000 newly issued ordinary shares with a par value of 0.25 Baht per share. These newly issued ordinary shares will be allocated to support the issuance and offering of shares to persons in a private placement (PP), representing 23.82% of the total number of shares to be issued and offered by the Company after the PP. The Company has scheduled an Extraordinary General Meeting of Shareholders No. 1/2025 to be held on March 5, 2025.


This issuance and offering of newly issued ordinary shares is considered a material offering of newly issued shares to persons in a private placement according to the Notification of the Capital Market Supervisory Board No. Tor Jor. 28/2022. This is because the offering may result in the allottees becoming the shareholders with the highest voting rights in the Company. Therefore, the Company must appoint an Independent Financial Advisor (IFA) to provide opinions to the shareholders on the following matters: (1) the appropriateness of the offering price and conditions; (2) the reasonableness and benefits of the offering to investors, including the plan for utilizing the proceeds from the offering, compared to the impact on existing shareholders; and (3) the opinion on whether the shareholders should approve the offering, along with the reasons. Additionally, the offering must be approved by the shareholders' meeting with no less than 3/4 of the total votes of the shareholders present and entitled to vote.


In the aforementioned report, the Independent Financial Advisor (IFA) is of the opinion that the Company's offering of newly issued ordinary shares to persons in a private placement is reasonable. This is due to the reasonableness and appropriateness of the objectives, conditions, and offering price of the capital increase, as well as the Company's plan for utilizing the proceeds and the benefits it will receive. The advantages and disadvantages of participating in and not participating in the transaction were also considered. Therefore, the IFA is of the opinion that the shareholders' meeting should approve the issuance and offering of the capital increase.

Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements

Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements Issued?

Yes

Can the Company Maintain the Reported Financial Ratios?

Yes

Explanation

As of December 31, 2017, according to the debentures issued and offered for sale by East Coast Furnitech Public Company Limited, which have the conditions for maintaining Financial Covenants as specified in the terms and conditions of each series of debentures, as follows: the issuer shall maintain the ratio of "Debt" to "Equity" (Interest Bearing Debt to Equity Ratio) at a ratio not exceeding 4:1 (four to one).

As of the end of the issuer's quarterly or annual accounting period, which is based on the consolidated financial information and the company's status as of December 31, 2017, the company was able to maintain the said ratio at 2.43 times, which is still within the specified conditions.

Factors That May Affect Financial Condition

Factors or Incidents That May Materially Affect Financial Condition

Since 2016, the Company has expanded its business into the renewable energy business until December 31, 2020. The Company has invested in solar power plant projects (after December 24, 2020, the Company sold all of its ordinary shares held through its associated company, Safe Energy Holdings Co., Ltd., which invests in the biomass power plant business, and was able to close the sale on that date and received a total of 233.88 million baht in share sales). ECF Power Co., Ltd., a subsidiary in which the Company holds a 99.99 percent stake, is the investor in the project. It may be a significant factor or event affecting the Company's future financial position or operations, namely,

Risk from project success / Risk from project commencement later than planned, which in the case of the solar power plant project in Minbu City, Myanmar, through a 20 percent stake in Green Earth Power (Thailand) Co., Ltd. As of December 31, 2024, the project is still under construction for phases 2, 3, and 4, totaling 170 megawatts out of a total of 220 megawatts. In the past, the key risks that have been obstacles causing the construction to be delayed from the plan are the unrest in Myanmar. The COVID-19 pandemic in the past has resulted in the need to delay travel to the project construction site.


However, the latest progress of the construction of Phase 2 is that the site preparation for the installation of solar panels has been completed. Including ordering products such as solar panels with installation accessories necessary for construction, it can proceed according to the plan. However, the impact of COVID-19 and the political unrest that occurred in the past have affected the commercial operation date for the next phases, which will have to be delayed from the original plan. The management team and staff are well aware of these issues, and currently, the construction team will accelerate the construction as much as possible to minimize such impacts. In accordance with the terms of the power purchase agreement, the project can claim Force Majeure from the impact of COVID-19 and the political unrest that occurred in Myanmar during the past. At present, the project has not yet been notified to warn of the delay in the construction of the project from the relevant government agencies of Myanmar. In addition, the project continues to receive regular electricity payments from the Myanmar government for the Phase 1 power plant project, which has been commercially operational since September 2019 until now.


In addition, in order to closely monitor the project management and mitigate various risks, the Company has sent its representatives to attend the meeting and serve as directors of Green Earth Power (Thailand) Co., Ltd. The Company's representatives attended the meeting and listened to the progress, including problems and solutions to ensure that the project proceeds according to the plan closely. The representatives will present the details to the Company's Board of Directors meeting for acknowledgment of the progress of the project construction, including the results of the completed Phase 1 project with a capacity of 50 megawatts, continuously at every Board of Directors meeting.


Currently, the Company has no obligation to inject additional capital under any conditions to the power plant project. The Company expects that the construction of the power plant project for Phase 2 will be able to commercially distribute electricity within 2025.

Projects or R&D Affecting Future Results

None

Contents